First up is the right back position and I think the answer is clearly NOT OBVIOUS in this case as both are extremely good, extremely fit, extremely motivated and extremely competitive. One thing to note about both these defenders is that they both made their BIG money move (to Barcelona and Real Madrid) while playing at Sevilla.
For Sergio Ramos, I still remember the season where he scored a cracker of a long range free kick against Real Madrid and won the game for Sevilla. Next season, he was wearing the white shirt such was his impact. Sergio Ramos is 23 years old and already has played over 150 games for Real Madrid and is definitely one of those players who are looked upon as future Rauls for Real Madrid.
Daniel Alves on the other hand is 3 years Ramos’s senior and is equally as talented. I wanted him to come to Real Madrid for the simple reason that his arrival would have meant that Sergio Ramos would have moved in the central defense and Ramos Pepe pair would have been the best in Europe (assuming Ramos learns to keep his head). But, it was not to be and Daniel Alves signed for Barcelona (man I so wished Chelsea would have signed him, but they signed a pretty good right back themselves who goes by the name of Bosingwa).
Anyway, here are their individual stats.
Sergio Ramos
Real Madrid
Spanish League: 2006-07, 2007-08
Spanish Supercup: 2008
Spain
UEFA European Championship: 2008
Spain (youth level)
UEFA U-19 Championship: 2004
Individual
UEFA’s Best new player of 2004-05[citation needed]
UEFA’s 2005-06 All-World Defensive Player of the Year
Don Balón Award for Breakthrough Player of the Year: 2005
Antonio Puerta Award.[1]
ESM Team of the year: 2007-08
ESM Team of the Month: April 2007, May 2007, September 2007, October 2007, November 2007, December 2007, January 2008
FIFPro World XI: 2007-08
Móstoles Sports Elite Award[2]
UEFA Team of the Year: 2008[3]
FIFA.com Team of the Year: 2008
Daniel Alves
Club
Bahia
Nordeste Championship: (2) 2001, 2002
Bahia State League: (1) 2001
Sevilla
UEFA Cup: (2) 2005-06, 2006-07
UEFA Super Cup: (1) 2006
Spanish Cup: (1) 2006-07
Spanish Supercup: (1) 2007
Barcelona
Spanish League: (1) 2008-09
Spanish Cup: (1) 2008-09
Spanish Supercup: (1) 2009
UEFA Champions League: (1) 2008-09
UEFA Super Cup: (1) 2009
FIFA Club World Cup: (1) 2009
International
FIFA World Youth Championship: 2003
Copa América: 2007
FIFA Confederations Cup: 2009
Individual
UEFA Cup Most Valuable Player : 2006
UEFA Super Cup Most Valuable Player : 2006
UEFA Team of the Year : 2007
Best Defender : 2008-09 (LFP)
(Source www.wikipedia.com)
Now, According to me, their ON FIELD ability COMPARISON goes like this:
Daniel Alves | Sergio Ramos
Acceleration 9 8
Aggression 8 8
Agility 8 7
Balance 7 8
Ball Control 8 8
Crossing 8 7
Curve75
Dribbling 8 7
Finishing 6 5
Free kick 8 6
Header 7 9
Jump 7 8
Long Pass 8 7
Long Shots 8 5
Marking 8 8
Positioning 8 8
Reaction 8 7
Short Pass 8 7
Shot Power 8 7
Slide Tackle 8 8
Sprint Speed 8 8
Stamina 9 8
Standing Tackle 8 8
Strength 7 8
Tactical Awareness 7 6
I ll touch on few of these points briefly
SPEED:
Draw
Both of them a really really quick. There is one difference though. Daniel Alves runs with long fluid smooth strides (more like how Federer moves on the court, sorry for persistingwithFootballTenniscomparison)whereasSergioRamos
how can you give daniu alves better speed and dribbling????? are you blind??? ramos is proven to one of the fastest in world football, are u crazy??? and I don’t think that i need to talk about his dribbling skills which sometimes look exactly like cristiano ronaldos!! and his agility!! the only thing dani alves has over ramos is aggression and shooting….god you are one crazy person to deny stuff that stares you in the face
hi,
football is a very-very old and fantastic game.
thanks.
sergio ramos all day
for me sergio ramos is the best right back position in the world dan alves
Both are equally good but Ramos looks better physically, also Ramos has thebetter header.
in my opinion, in the right back position, alves can compete with ramos, but as a defender, ramos is better because he is more versatile, thus making him more valuable for the team, furthermore, the legendary maldini stated that ramos is his heir, so…